Tucson, Ariz. – A collection of cast-lead crosses and swords found near Tucson has led to a controversy now nearly a century old: Did Romans establish a colony in the area around C.E. 800?
Some are convinced the crosses are proof. Others say it’s a hoax.
The objects were unearthed by Charles Manier and his family in 1924 after digging through layers of hardened sediment known as caliche. Among the artifacts found was a 64-pound, 20-inch-long lead cross.
Listen to an interview with Arizona History Museum Curator Julie Arriola:
Some believe the objects are evidence that Jews from Rome settled the area around C.E. 800.
A 2016 article in Epoch Times quotes a medieval scholar as saying he believes the artifacts are real.
But those who doubt their authenticity point to some of the inscriptions on the objects as standard literary quotations cribbed from Latin grammar books.
Both the Smithsonian Institution and British Museum had a look at the artifacts.
A curator for the former opined that their source could be a “mentally incompetent individual with a flair for old Latin and the wars of antiquity.”
The Arizona History Museum now owns the Tucson artifacts. I spoke with curator Julia Arriola in 2011 about the ongoing controversy.